Let's Learn Organon of Medicine with Dr Prasad Rasal...
Lecture no.7, Compiled by Dr Shukleshwar Tribhuvan:
Dr Samuel Hahnemann: The Scientific Experimenter
Lecture no.7, Compiled by Dr Shukleshwar Tribhuvan:
Dr Samuel Hahnemann: The Scientific Experimenter
-Dr Hahnemann in all essential, a flawless experimenter.
-We all know the experiment of Peruvian Barks.
-If Hahnemann should not have experimented on himself but on dogs, or cats, or rats, or mice, has not entered the school of scientific logic.
-Disease manifests itself not merely by objective signs of sensory impressions, but also by subjective symptoms of motor expression.
-can the human experimenter record the subjective feelings of dogs, and cats, and rats, and mice cannot communicate to his understanding by their subjective feelings?
-There are no two human beings entirely the same in health and disease.
-Are dogs, or cats, or mice, or rats more nearly like to human beings are like to one another?
- The experimenter experiments but does not know why he is experiments.
- The moral justification may be that the he experiments because he is paid to experiment; but where is the scientific justification?
- Hahnemann had scientific justification for his experiments.
- That is the reason why his experiments were not sterile.
- Experimentation is for one of two purposes, observation for induction, or verification of inductions.
- Experimentation is analysis, deduction, analytic deduction.
- Hahnemann experimented for observation.
to be continued...
-We all know the experiment of Peruvian Barks.
-If Hahnemann should not have experimented on himself but on dogs, or cats, or rats, or mice, has not entered the school of scientific logic.
-Disease manifests itself not merely by objective signs of sensory impressions, but also by subjective symptoms of motor expression.
-can the human experimenter record the subjective feelings of dogs, and cats, and rats, and mice cannot communicate to his understanding by their subjective feelings?
-There are no two human beings entirely the same in health and disease.
-Are dogs, or cats, or mice, or rats more nearly like to human beings are like to one another?
- The experimenter experiments but does not know why he is experiments.
- The moral justification may be that the he experiments because he is paid to experiment; but where is the scientific justification?
- Hahnemann had scientific justification for his experiments.
- That is the reason why his experiments were not sterile.
- Experimentation is for one of two purposes, observation for induction, or verification of inductions.
- Experimentation is analysis, deduction, analytic deduction.
- Hahnemann experimented for observation.
to be continued...
No comments:
Post a Comment